Are Patents Good or Bad?

Are patents good or bad? Patents are bad for those who cannot afford the patented products (e.g. 10% of essential drugs are patented). However, it is fairly good in ensuring innovation, granting licenses fees for innovators, and giving smaller businesses a means to compete on technology.

Patently-O, Dennis Crouch, the co-director of the Center for Intellectual Property & Entrepreneurship at the University of Missouri School of Law, points out that about 50% of patents expire prematurely because their owners decline to pay the required maintenance fees.

There is merit in the claim that patents are bad in many ways for consumers, particularly when intellectual protectionism or monopolism harms the public interest and impedes competition which drives innovation. However, intellectual property rights in the form of patents play a part in recognizing the efforts of authors, inventors, and producers, allowing them to survive in the industry. As such, patents are good for these particular groups of people. 

At a glance, here are 4 ways that patents are good for people with serious business.

  1. Patents protect investments in research and development

One of the key reasons businesses apply for patents is to prevent competitors from copying their innovations. Businesses that have a patent granted for an invention prevents and deter third parties from exploiting it and freely reaping the benefits of the time and money invested in research and development.

  1. Patents secure exclusivity and market position

Blocking competitors from exploiting your invention can allow your business to establish a dominant market position and brand reputation.

It is not always necessary to wait until a third party starts marketing an infringing product before enforcing your patent right – in some cases, the courts can grant an interim injunction to pre-emptively stop a potential infringer from entering the market, to begin with. Merely having a patent can also act as a deterrent even without legal action, as the possibility of litigation might be enough to put off more cautious competitors.

Obtaining a portfolio of patents in other countries can also pave the way for entry into international markets, giving your product a head start over local rivals.

  1. Patents grant licensing

Patent owners may wish to grant permission for a third party to use their invention in return for royalties. Licensing can be great for start-ups who don’t have the money or facilities to manufacture or market a product themselves, while still retaining commercial benefit from the invention. Licensing can also be useful in international markets to take advantage of the knowledge of local distributors.

In some cases, it may be possible to negotiate cross-licenses for patents owned by competitors. This is particularly important in cases where patents held by two different companies have an overlapping scope, and so neither company has the freedom to operate without a license from the other.

  1. Patents defend against attacks from larger rivals

Start-up ventures may occasionally be founded on a new development of existing technology, rather than a brand new technology. This can leave growing companies vulnerable to litigation by larger, corporate owners of patents covering the underlying technology.

If a large proprietor seeks an injunction to prevent the use of their patented technology, this will also block the use of any new developments of the technology, which could be fatal for a start-up company relying on being able to exploit their new developments. By patenting their developments, smaller businesses have some means to defend themselves in such a situation, by counter-suing and negotiating a settlement.

The Bad Side of Patents

Despite the seemingly attractive benefits that patents may bring, intellectual property rights are expensive to upkeep and leave consumers bearing the brunt of the costs. The world may be worse off for the ordinary man when consumer goods, patented by businesses in the interest of protecting their rights, become less affordable. 

In a fictional context, the removal of intellectual property rights will mean the legitimization of the current black market for piracy and plagiarism. Rather than paying for legal merchandise at authorized retailers, one can simply visit any of the newly legal ‘pirate’ vendors and purchase the same merchandise at a fraction of the price. In the short run, many people will benefit without patents.

Given the high expenses eventually shouldered by consumers as a result of the system of intellectual property protection, patents are seemingly bad in the eyes of the majority of consumers.

The risks of capitalizing on the ‘Good’ patents may bring

Critics of patents and copyrights maintain that the poor will be better off without the system of intellectual property rights which hampers their access to necessities, particularly in the healthcare sector.

Under the World Health Organisation List of Essential Medicines which is revised every 2 years, there is a growing trend of essential drugs being patented, growing from 5.4% in 2013 to 10.3% as of May 2020. (geneva-network.com)

The prevalence of such campaigns and movements in developing countries highlights the plight of the poor who are denied healthcare essentials, and who might be better off without the system of intellectual property rights. 

While businesses or individuals may have applied for patents to credit and protect the work they have poured their hearts into, the unintendedly insensitive and unethical outcomes it may bring to less privileged communities may cause patents to backfire on themselves.

Under what circumstances can patents be ‘fairly good’?

Patents can be claimed to be ‘fairly good’ when the outcome of patenting generates positive externalities on top of protecting their rights.

For example, after Apple’s 2012 landmark lawsuit against Samsung which determined that Samsung was to pay Apple more than USD1 billion in damages for infringing on a series of Apple’s patents on mobile devices, companies have begun considering how much they want their product to look and feel like their competitors’ products in terms of shape, size, the way they feel, the way they look, how icons are similar, or how the icons are dissimilar. This development has allowed consumers to enjoy some welcome diversity in phone and tablet design. 

Hence, patents can be ‘fairly good’ when it functions as a necessary impetus for innovation, which can consequently lead to mutually beneficial outcomes for businesses and consumers alike.

Conclusion

Patents are an integral part of business plans and an aspect of development that is unlikely to be neglected. While patents may offer a wealth of benefits, it may be worthwhile for businesses to foresee potential unintended consequences of patenting, debate ethical standpoints, and weigh the net outcome of their decision to patent before doing so. 


Efforts have been made to get the information as accurate and updated as possible. If you found any incorrect information with credible source, please send it via the contact us form

Darryl Ang
Darryl was born and raised in Singapore, the Little Red Dot situated at the heart of Asia. Growing up, he realised his interest in research, consumer psychology and entrepreneurship, which have motivated him to participate in multiple national-level entrepreneurial projects for which he clinched recognisable accolades. As a young and aspiring business consultant, he is now interning at a local business development and marketing consultancy firm to nurture his passion, and pursue his mission of helping businesses while contributing towards positive social changes. Through his knowledge and experience, he hopes to create more appealing articles that can impact businesses.


What Others are Reading

Is Private Tutoring Worth It In Singapore?
Is Private Tutoring Worth It In Singapore?
Since the start of the 21st century, the tutoring industry has been picking up steam, particularly in Asia where pape...
Read More
Why Do The Rich Get Away With Everything
Why Do The Rich Get Away With Everything
  How true is the statement “Money is power”? From the affluenza teen who got away with murder, to Malaysia’s former ...
Read More
Edinburgh Festival Fringe Complete Guide
Edinburgh Festival Fringe Complete Guide
From BookingMentor. Are you an art fanatic wondering how to prepare for Edinburgh Festival Fringe?” We will look at ...
Read More
What Causes Academic Pressure
What Causes Academic Pressure
According to the American Psychological Association's latest Stress in America report, 87% of college students report...
Read More
How Activism Changed The World (With Examples)
How Activism Changed The World (With Examples)
Activism today is more widespread than ever. Considering the paradigm shifts in our social climate, how did activism ...
Read More
Does Success Come More Easily To Men Than Women? (With Examples)
Does Success Come More Easily To Men Than Women? (With Examples)
Does success come more easily to men than women? Success arguably comes easier to men than women, especially in Sing...
Read More
Differentiating the Sensors & Intuitives (S vs N)
Differentiating the Sensors & Intuitives (S vs N)
MBTI has been making waves in popular culture in recent times, with the Instagram account @mbti.memess having 112,000...
Read More
How Many Hours To Work On A Website (After Spending Thousands)
How Many Hours To Work On A Website (After Spending Thousands)
As a someone who sold simple websites to legacy companies (with a few friends), and started multiple eCommerce websit...
Read More